In early 1966, the Knickerbockers hit the Top 20 with "Lies," the best and most accurate early Beatle imitation ever recorded; the lead vocals were a dead ringer for John Lennon and the whole production could have fit in snugly on the second side of A Hard Day's Night.
Actually a frat rock band from New Jersey who didn't write much of their own material, they never made anything else as successful. A couple decent follow-ups -- "One Track Mind" and the similarly mock-British Invasion "High on Love" -- were small hits, but their albums were even blander than many of the era's other one-shot artists. Their three noteworthy singles were all featured in Rhino's Nuggets series. Drummer and singer Jimmy Walker briefly replaced Bill Medley in the Righteous Brothers. ~ Richie Unterberger
The band was formed in 1962 in Bergenfield, New Jersey by brothers Beau Charles (guitar & vocals) and John Charles (bass & vocals) (birth names: Robert and John Carlos Cecchino respectively) with fluctuating personnel until 1964, when they met Buddy Randell (vocals & sax) (birth name: William Crandall). Buddy was previously of the Rockin' Saints and the Royal Teens, who had a hit with "Short Shorts" in 1958. They took their name from Knickerbocker Road, which ran through the town next to their hometown.
The classic line-up consisted of Randell, the Charles brothers and drummer Jimmy Walker (previously the drummer with the Massena-based Atco Records act The Castle Kings in New York). They were spotted by producer and singer-songwriter Jerry Fuller playing the University Twist Palace in Albany, New York, and he subsequently signed them to Los Angeles-based Challenge Records.
Throughout The Knickerbockers three years of recordings, the group tirelessly pursued current trends; the vocals on "Jerk Town," for example, are heavily derivative of the Four Seasons. (Furthermore, the song's lyrics refer to "hot rods," like so many other popular songs of the day). Finally, The Knickerbockers had a Top 20 hit in early 1966 with "Lies." Somewhat ironically, the song is most famous today for being blatantly derivative of contemporary songs by The Beatles, down to the imitation of John Lennon on the lead vocal and the Paul McCartney-style vocal whoops before the guitar solo and later in the song. Allmusic remarks that the song is "justly regarded as the most accurate early-Beatles imitation."  Some listeners, unaware of its true source, mistake it for being a "lost" Beatles track.
The follow-up to the smash "Lies" was "One Track Mind", and it was nearly a hit as well. Unfortunately, the band's label, Challenge Records, couldn't handle the distribution, and the single only reached number 45. The Knickerbockers soldiered on, appearing in the movie Out of Sight (1966) and as regulars on Dick Clark's ABC-TV program, Where the Action Is (1965–1967).
Though the band had a strong songwriter in Beau Charles, the group was hampered by their label's ineptness, and drummer Walker left in late 1967 to replace Bill Medley in The Righteous Brothers. Walker would also record three solo singles for Columbia Records in 1968–1969, before retiring to Wyoming for much of the 1970s. Buddy Randell was the next to depart. The Charles brothers kept the band going by adding new members Richie Walker (vocals), Ron Mercier (drums) and Barry McCoy (keyboards) and moving the act to San Francisco. Randell rejoined The Knickerbockers on drums in 1968, leaving again in 1970 (McCoy departed to join Gary Puckett and The Union Gap). Buddy later recorded singles for Uni records ("Randi, Randi"/"Be My Baby" 1970) and under aliases such as Steel Wool ("No Sugar Tonight" White Whale 1969) and Blowtorch ("I Want Sugar all the Time" Paramount Records 1971). Beau Charles was also active outside of the group, too, waxing "Sharon Stay in Birmingham" for White Whale Records under the alias of Columbus Jones in 1969. (Both of the White Whale and Uni Records singles were produced or co-produced by George Tobin, who later went on to produce and manage 1980s teenage singer, Tiffany).
Other projects and reformation
Beau and John Charles, along with singer Ritchie Costanza and drummer Eric Swanson, were signed to Motown records in 1971, where their name was subsequently changed to Lodi.[disambiguation needed] They recorded an album (released in 1972) and one single ("Happiness" / "I Hope I See it In My Lifetime") on the Mowest subsidiary, before splitting up.
The Charles brothers and Randell then briefly backed up Playboy Records artist Brenda Patterson in 1973–1974, most notably appearing on an episode of The Midnight Special. Beau Charles remained the most visible member of the band throughout the 1970s, appearing in an episode of Harry-O as a lounge singer, and performing on various film and television soundtracks.
Since then, The Knickerbockers have reformed twice. The first time was in 1983 in Los Angeles, with everyone except Buddy Randell (he was singing with the faith-based band Jerusalem Rivers at the time). They recorded demos with producer Jerry Fuller, but split up soon afterward. The band reformed one more time, performing for a month in Delray Beach, Florida, in 1990, before disbanding again.
Beau and John Charles have been involved with The Knickerbockers' CD releases on Sundazed Records. Buddy Randell died in 1998.
The band's two most popular singles are on the box set Nuggets: Original Artyfacts From the First Psychedelic Era, and there are numerous re-issues and rarity sets. A compilation album by the band is The Fabulous Knickerbockers, released on Sundazed Records.
•"All I Need is You" / "Bite Bite Barracuda" (Challenge 59268) 1964
•"Jerktown" / "Room for One More" (Challenge 59293) 1965
•"Lies / "The Coming Generation" (Challenge 59321) 1965 U.S. #20
•"One Track Mind" / "I Must Be Doing Something Right" (Challenge 59326) 1966 U.S. #46
•"High on Love" / "Stick With Me" (Challenge 59332) 1966 U.S. #94
•"Chapel in the Fields" / "Just One Girl" (Challenge 59335) 1966
•"Love is a Bird" / "Rumors, Gossip, Words Untrue" (Challenge 59341) 1966
•"Please Don't Love Him" / "Can You Help Me" (Challenge 59348) 1966
•"What Does That Make You?" / "Sweet Green Fields" (Challenge 59359) 1967
•"Come and Get It" / "Wishful Thinking" (Challenge 59366) 1967
•"I Can Do It Better" / "You'll Never Walk Alone" (Challenge 59380) 1967
•"A Matter of Fact" / "They Ran For Their Lives" (Challenge 59384) 1968
•"Happiness" / "Hope I See it In My Lifetime" (as LODI) (MoWest 5003) 1971
•"All I Need is You" / "Jerktown" (reissue) (Sundazed #unknown) 1989
•"Gotta Stop This Dreaming" / "I Want a Girl for Christmas" (Sundazed SEP 186) 2006
•"Lies" / "The Coming Generation" / "One Track Mind" / "I Must Be Doing Something Right" (London 10178) 1966
•Lloyd Thaxton Presents.... (Challenge 1264) 1965
•Jerk & Twine (Challenge 621) 1966
•LiesS (Challenge 622) 1966 U.S.
•Lodi (MoWest MW 101L) 1972
•The Great Lost Knickerbockers Album! (Sundazed) 1989
1. The Knickerbockers - Lies (Are Breaking My Heart) (2:43)
2. The Knickerbockers - One Track Mind (2:21)
3. The Knickerbockers - I Can Do It Better (2:21)
4. The Knickerbockers - Just One Girl (2:06)
5. The Knickerbockers - I Must Be Doing Something Right (2:39)
6. The Knickerbockers - Chuck Berry Medley: Johnny B. Goode
-Roll Over Beethoven-Sweet Little Sixteen-Johnny B. Goode (3:02)
7. The Knickerbockers - High On Love (3:03)
8. The Knickerbockers - Stick With Me (2:33)
9. The Knickerbockers - Love Is A Bird (2:35)
10. The Knickerbockers - I Love (2:57)
11. The Knickerbockers - They Ran For Their Lives (2:08)
12. The Knickerbockers - My Feet Are Off The Ground (2:16)
13. The Knickerbockers - She Said Goodbye (2:53)
14. The Knickerbockers - You're Bad (2:22)
15. The Knickerbockers - What Does That Make You (2:36)
16. The Knickerbockers - Rumors, Gossip, Words Untrue (2:40)
17. The Knickerbockers - Comin' Generation (3:14)
18. The Knickerbockers - Can't You See I'm Tryin' (2:23)
19. The Knickerbockers - Sweet Green Fields (2:42)
20. The Knickerbockers - Give A Little Bit (2:17)
21. The Knickerbockers - Guaranteed Satisfaction